I’ve gotten really bad about thinking of good topics for this blog–which is not a good thing. A really good blog shouldn’t feel forced, I think. But the main topics in my life right now are either “recovering from surgery” which is boring and not really tasteful, and “renewed focus on Bible Study” which is sometimes too personal and too much inside baseball.
The other day Sharon asked a very good question that I was going to leave in a comment, but then I realised–hey! It’s a whole blog entry.
Do you study from the ancient Celtic perspective? I know you’ve studied Judaism, did you ever study Zohar and Kabbalah? …
Anyhow, I don’t think I could relate to Judaism if I didn’t study it with a strong emphasis on the mysticism parts.
Et tu, regarding Christianity?
The short answer is yes, and yes and yes and yes. The longer answer is, well, longer for many reasons.
I was born into Christianity, with Christian parents and grandparents and cousins and aunts and uncles. My grandmother even had three pomeranians one time called Shirley, Goodness and Mercy. (Psalm 23:6 says “Surely goodness and mercy will follow me all the days of my life” and since her dogs followed her everywhere…) I went to Christian schools and learned the Common Christianity of the middle class Midwest. That’s a beautiful religion in its matter-of-factness. There is no official catechism, but the unwritten foundation is “Life is hard; our sin nature makes it so. Christ redeemed us through his death and resurrection, so we muddle through this hard world with God’s help and hope for heaven after death.” When you’re farmers, you have a very good understanding of God’s curse in Genesis that man shall till the soil with the sweat of his brow to earn food.
Two strange events happened in my early years that shaped the course of my study into something slightly different. Firstly, when I was eight months old I got pneumonia and was near death, with my heart stopping several times, I think. (I need to get better details from my parents because my memory of this event is non-existent to say the least.) Secondly, when I was eight years old my parents were late picking me up from church camp, so I went home with my grandmother. She was the doctor who adopted my father and his brother, but she was always their “real parent”. Right around that time, though, my father’s birth mother had apparently started to contact Grandma Doc to get information about the sons she gave away. I think this was on my grandmother’s mind, so she talked to me a bit about the blood parentage of my father. What was actually said is the matter of some debate in my family, but I did come away from that conversation with the understanding that my father’s birth parents were Jewish. So I spent years–literally YEARS–studying Hebrew and Judaic theologies, including Kabbalah and the Zohar. (I beat Madonna’s interest in Kabbalah–or, in her case, “Kabbalahish Lite”–by a good decade and a half.)
In my Senior year of High School I decided that I had been spared death as a baby for some sort of reason as yet undetermined. When I got to college I had a philosophy professor who was born in Germany, reborn in Christ and literally wrote the book on Mysticism in Evangelical Christianity. At his suggestion I began to read various mystical texts from a foundational World View (Weltangschaung) of Evangelical Christianity, specifically Mennonism. I’ve read pretty much everything from Crowley to Zwingli, and stranger bedfellows you will not find.
I’m not unusual. Most Christians are mystical to a degree, conversing with the Holy Spirit during their private devotional times. However, because this is such a foundational part of Christianity we don’t think of it as mysticism per se. We’re a funny people who think of Mysticism as the province of Maharishis and Yogis, yet still talk to the spirit of God on a daily basis. Studying mysticism is sort of like trying to see the wind. It’s still a beautiful experience, though, and one which wholly enriches my life.
There are a number of definitions of mysticism that limit it only to ecstatic oneness with the divine spirit. This is bothering me right now because (coincidentally) I’m in the middle of A.J. Heschel’s book on the prophets, and he is very firm about contrasting prophecy to (and separating it from) mysticism, which he finds limited in that way. Now, I love Heschel, and I find what he has to say about prophecy quite moving and persuasive, but I keep arguing with him in my head about mysticism, which isn’t even his main topic.
nm–
His father was a great Rebbe, but when Heschel became a Rabbi, I believe it was in the late 30s, and around a time many Jews were experiencing existential crisis’s.
I find him interesting on an intellectual level, but on a spiritual level, he leaves me empty.
BTW, we have a program at Sherith Israel where we study with a study partner on Tuesday afternoons, and you’d be more than welcome. We’re also getting ready to start Kabbalah classes again in the evening starting in a few weeks.
Do you know Margot Nash? (Sarah Rivka) She’s my best female friend in Nashville, and is head of Sisterhood at Sherith. She’s Hasidic, and she runs a lot of these classes. I’d be more than happy to tell her about you if you would like to join.
Kat has my phone number, and you can call me for more info, or email me, MissSharonCobb@aol.com.
Kat–
Thanks for answering my question. There’s so much I don’t know about Christian mysticism. It seems to me from the little I’ve read, the Counsel of Nicea struck a lot of parts of the Christian Bible that dealt reincarnation and transmigration and whatnot to control the people.
What’s your take on that?
Different strokes; Heschel’s insights have gotten me through some very difficult times. And thanks for the invite — it sounds like an admirable program, and it amazes me that the Orthodox provide this for women in Nashville while the Conservative don’t. But unfortunately my job is completely inflexible about hours and I can’t get away in the afternoons.
nm–
I used to belong to West End, and rarely were there even get togethers for everyone. For a while, we had a semi private (elitist?) study group with Rabbi Roth and 10 hand picked people, (picked by Roth) but that was several years ago.
The Hasids are very good about outreach, and the Hasidic women are big time into taking control of their own studies and lives.
Hasids are very big on studying not just Torah, but mysticism. Most of the villages where the Rebbes came from in Russia based their sects on mysticism. (You probably know that…just letting you know in case you didn’t know that)
When we start night classes again in Kabbalah, let me know if you’re interested.
BTW, the women are great and very friendly and never try to push their level of observance on anyone else.
I wear leggings and usually a John Lennon or Beatles tee shirt and don’t cover my hippie hair. It’s all very laid back and fun. They’re very kind.
Please feel free to join us when night classes start.
Um, I should have said that it would amaze me that the Conservative congregation here doesn’t offer study groups if anything about that congregation amazed me any more. And, in keeping with the concept of different strokes for different folks, that’s all I’ll say about that.