I don’t usually post Spoiler Warnings on my Lost posts, because I figure any good discussion of a show after the show has aired will have spoilers in it and most reasonable people could, would and should expect that without the post’s author holding their hand. Tonight is different. Tonight’s episode was the season finale and has big stuff that I’m going to talk, whine, laugh or grouse about. And I don’t want any of you to read this post before watching the show and think to yourself “Wow. Now I hate Coble as much as Coble hates Jack.” Because you’d be wrong. No, you wouldn’t be wrong to hate me, but you would be wrong to think you hate me as much as I hate Jack. Because I truly don’t think it’s possible. Sometimes I wonder if I hate Jack as much as I hate Jack. And then I tell myself that hate is wrong. But then I tell myself that Jack is fictional, so hating him is not as wrong as hating, say, a blogger who spoils the Season Finale of Lost.
Okay. Here’s the part where I come clean and admit that I figured this was what was up. Between some article I read that said this season finale would “turn the flashback structure on its ear” and the fact that the title of this episode was Through The Looking Glass, I kinda gathered that this would be an episode where the Island part was flashback and the gritty real-world part was the Now.
What I didn’t expect was that the Real World Now part would be Requiem For A Dream. Do I pity Jack for being a suicidal alcoholic junkie? Are you kidding? Absolutely not. Leave it to Jack to suffer in the most self-absorbed way possible once he gets around to suffering. And now, on to the bullet points, because my thoughts are so jumbled and I can’t write in cohesive paragraph form right now. Ah! A tribute to the writers of Lost! An inability to create coherent connective tissue that ties together salient points! Anyway…on with it.
- Oh, John Locke! How you at last lived up to your namesake by forcing Jack to follow his free will and fall victim to the consequences which followed. While I admire the thematic philosophy behind your actions, I ask you. How hard is it to pull a trigger?
- Walt is now approximately forty-five. Nice try shooting him with a low camera angle, but no one is fooled. That kid is now discussing IRAs over golf at the club. Now either The Producers were trying to convince us that he was still a wee lad or the Mystery Of Walt’s Age is another Island conundrum.
- Back in The Now, Jack kept referencing his father as though Christian Shepherd (you know, I’ve never even bothered to touch on the symbolism of that name. Anyone else wanna give it a go?) were still alive. Now that means one of two things. Either Jack has gone round the twist entirely and is so clearly nutwhacky as to be disregarded OR the Island has worked some time-magic whereby Christian Shepherd returned alive with the rest of the Lostlings.
- A few weeks ago, I mentioned that the shots of Charlie being shot through with an arrow reminded me of St. Sebastian.And now again tonight, St. Sebastian shows up in two places. It’s the name of Jack’s hospital, a fact we glean from the voice-over news coverage of Jack’s It’s A Wonderful Life “Clarence” moment. Then we have the oblique reference when Mikhail, shot with an arrow, comes back to life long enough to blow Charlie’s porthole. [diiiirty!] So of course I think it’s important that we look at a few things about St. Sebastian.
- He is associated with healing during the plague. So the island itself–which heals a variety of plagues–can be a figure of St. Sebastian.
- He is the patron saint of soldiers and policemen–Sayid and Ana Lucia
- He is of a class of saints known as athleta Christi, or Atheletes of Christ who are guardians of the heavens. Remember Desmond running his race?
- He is associated with resurrection, since he didn’t die after the arrows pierced him.
Clearly the writers have some import associated with St. Sebastian that they want us to know about.
- I do give the writers credit for a couple of things. It was nice that they made the key to disarming the switch a musical series that Charlie was the most likely to remember. It answered the question of why they went to all the trouble to keep Charlie alive only to kill him now. He served a purpose, much like Owen Meany. Of course, if I were to serve a larger purpose I’d hope it’d be more dramatic than remembering the notes to “Good Vibrations.” The other prop I give to the writers is the return of the Microbus. Granted, I thought that episode stood on its own merits, but it was nice to feel like they weren’t just fooling around.
- I’m resisting the urge to whine overmuch about the whole “person who takes drugs for legitimate medical reasons becomes an addict by default” storyline, but I will gripe about my other pet peeve. Yes, I realise Sawyer and Charlie were both trying to save Hurley by not letting him come along on their missions. But WHY ON EARTH does his weight have to be the excuse BOTH TIMES? Not only is it lazy writing, but it was also out of character for Charlie.
- Yay, Hurley saved the day. Seriously, make the show about Hurley.
- Whose funeral was it that broke Jack up so badly? I didn’t see the news clipping, and I realise it’s going to be yet another mystery that we’ll probably never have the answer to. Part of me wants to assume that it was Ben.
- So which “he” does Kate need to get back to? I guess we’re all to assume it’s Sawyer, but I’m sure that some big Sweeps Twist will reveal that it’s either Locke or some random guy like Hurley or Walt.
- Huh. I wonder why Kate’s not a fugitive. Or perhaps she is, and that’s why she had to meet Jack at Wayne and Garth’s Baberaham Lincoln plane-watching spot.
I swear, I think it was kind of a cool mindfrak that they stole from Battlestar Galactica’s Season 2 Finale did the time jump, but I’m a bit miffed that there are going to be so many new mysteries on top of the old ones. I mean, I’m still curious about the smoke monster, the polar bear, the Temple and Jacob. Now I’ve got to start figuring out real-world stuff, too. Oh well. I reckon we’ll have fun with it when the show comes back. In 2008.




Enjoyed your post. I’d bet you’d enjoy reading what the Network TV Slut had to say pre-finale on One Sorry Blog.
http://onesorryblog.wordpress.com/2007/05/23/network-tv-slut-or-what-lost-desperate-housewives-and-american-idol-have-to-do-with-your-life-5/
Of the season finales I’ve watched this month (3), all have been a bit disappointing and frustrating. I guess I prefer big cliffhanger season finales instead of a bunch of little loose ends just fluttering at the end with a bunch of different ways the whole storyline could go.
Malia, I’m with you. Except that I think I’m to the place where I’d just prefer a nice ending without any “Who Shot JR” hijinks.
If I haven’t told you, I adore your Lost posts.
[...] is going to take the agility of a gymnast today to avoid LOST spoilers. But, I do know this: what I’ve read makes me want to hurry up and catch up so I can see what [...]
1) I laughed out loud when I read, “how hard is it to pull a trigger?” — Yeah, I think I hate Jack too.
2) I love how Locke didn’t even acknowledge Ben; just ignored him like he was a piece of boring old furniture. Too cool.
3) I’m proud of Charlie.
4) Hurray for Hurley! Best rescue ever. And I love how he wasted no time taking complete and total credit for it all.
5) Re: Charlie’s weight comment to Hurley. It was his desperation to save Hurley that made him act completely out of character. And you could tell he regretted it the moment he said it.
6) So which “he” does Kate need to get back to? I guess we’re all to assume it’s Sawyer, but I’m sure that some big Sweeps Twist will reveal that it’s either Locke or some random guy like Hurley or Walt…. Huh. I wonder why Kate’s not a fugitive.
I was wondering the same things… but oh, gosh, not the Walt part!! Eewww! (PS – I vote for Sawyer)
7) Whoever died has to be someone Kate would possibly care about, because Jack thought she would attend the funeral. It could be Ben; she might go just to make sure he’s dead. But it’s more likely someone she once cared about but that doesn’t have anyone else — which probably means Sawyer. Which means my vote in #6 is cancelled. Drat!
8) I totally did not see that “flash forward” coming. I kept trying to figure out where the flashes fit in Jack’s “past” — and how the woman and child were related to the island. It had to smack me in the face before I got it. Perhaps I take the idea of being “in the moment” a bit too far….? Or maybe it was because I was watching it at midnight…
9) I read this last night but was waaaaaay too tired and loopy to comment. So I dreamed about it instead. Yeah, something is seriously wrong with me.
10) nothing else to say… I just thought there should be a ten.
It’s always been clear in the past that flashbacks are introduced by the “swoosh” sound. In in the episode “Flashes Before Your Eyes”, Desmond’s “flashbacks” didn’t have the swoosh sound. The producers have said there wasn’t a sound since it wasn’t a “real flashback”. This episode had no swoosh sound.
I don’t know what that means.
HM…I take that back. They did have the swoosh. How did I miss it?
Marc, to be honest, I only notice the “swoosh” intermittently.
So I wouldn’t have caught it, I don’t think.
Seriously. Is Walt on growth hormones or what?
Coble, I do not care how much you claim to hate Jack. There is no way you could possibly hate him more than I do. I would challenge you to a Jack hate-off if I didn’t think anything having to do with him would be time out of my life that I couldn’t get back. Hate. And you know what? Kate’s not that far behind. In other news, I would totally watch a Hurley spin off. And I think his neighbors should be Rose and Bernard. And Sun and Jin.
I took a class at God’s own Union University called Christian Symbolism in Theatre and Film in which we just watched a bunch of movies and extracted the Christian symbolism. You can find it in pretty much anything once you set your mind to it. But Charlie especially seemed to have a lot of christoid elements surrounding him this episode. I have been calling for his death for 2 seasons now, but they finally made him likeable in the episode where he got his. Ruining my sweet, sweet satisfaction. Nice. And also? Why the hell didn’t he just swim out of the porthole?
How hard is it to pull a trigger?
You think the gun would’ve worked? I thought as Locke put the gun to his head that that old revolver would either misfire or explode in his hand.
Nice try shooting him with a low camera angle, but no one is fooled.
Or they could’ve simply been shooting from Locke’s perspective, which was in a pit.
the Island has worked some time-magic whereby Christian Shepherd returned alive
Remember that Lost book, Bad Twin? I didn’t read it, there is another possibility. Which would mean that Jack and Claire aren’t related after all.
But WHY ON EARTH does his weight have to be the excuse BOTH TIMES?
I think Lu does a good job answering that one.
Whose funeral
My first thought too was Ben. Perhaps Locke.
So which “he” does Kate need to get back to?
Most likely Sawyer, but he’s all different now that he’s killed Locke’s father. He certainly didn’t hesitate to off Mr. Friendly.
I wonder why Kate’s not a fugitive.
I wondered the same. Other stuff I wondered about:
I’m not sure why Charlie had to sacrifice himself. That was a pretty huge chamber. If he’d left the door open they should’ve had plenty of time before it filled with water.
I guess either Juliet doesn’t make it off the island or something else happens between them?
Did we already ask why the walkie talkies work in spite of the jamming equipment?
You can find it in pretty much anything once you set your mind to it.
Lost is full of it (and I could end the sentence there, but I will continue) because Carlton Cuse has been rediscovering his Catholic roots in the story-telling elements. I forget where–EW, maybe–Cuse went on and on about how he’s let his Catholicism shape the show.
But Charlie especially seemed to have a lot of christoid elements surrounding him this episode.
I think they keep overdoing the sacrifice symbols. Especially when they aren’t sacrificing Jack. And I’m with you about them making Charlie likeable at the end. And the porthole thing.
I guess either Juliet doesn’t make it off the island or something else happens between them?
Good question. I think most of the next two years are going to be made up of “Oh, so THAT’s why he/she isn’t in the future” episodes.
Did we already ask why the walkie talkies work in spite of the jamming equipment?
I forgot to put that here. We discussed it at my house during the show.
Wait, I’m in on the Jack “Beat him in the head” Club.
Jack.
***sigh*** in a bad way.
I still think they need to make Sayid the leader. With those ninja moves last night I was, dare I say it, smitten.
Mad Skillz, I’m telling you.
With those ninja moves last night I was, dare I say it, smitten.
Please, woman. You’ve been smitten with the Jarrah for awhile now.
I must add, though, that the possibilities I inferred from the Ninja moves made me much more of a Sayid-fan.
The funeral home was shown to be in a run-down black neighborhood and the attendant was black. (Though that may just have been casting.) I think it was either Bernard or Rose who died; possibly Michael or Walt.
Did you notice the name of the home? “Hoffs/Drawler” is an anagram of “Flash Forward.”
Yup.
K-Co, you are right. Why do I dig the Sayid?
This I do not know.
I think it’s because he’s a hell of a lot smarter than their leader (snark) Jack.
Although.
The knee-neck-ankle killing thing was, dare I say it, groovy.
Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. Sayid.
the attendant was black. (Though that may just have been casting.)
No, I’m pretty sure that guy’s black all the time. ;-p
K-Co, you are right. Why do I dig the Sayid? …The knee-neck-ankle killing thing was, dare I say it, groovy.
… Mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. Sayid.
Power is an aphrodisiac. And, really, is there anything more powerful than a man who can kill with his feet? No. I don’t think so.
Power is an aphrodisiac. And, really, is there anything more powerful than a man who can kill with his feet? No. I don’t think so.
It’s been said that my feet can kill a person, but not in the same way that Sayid can.
Who knew that this would be an aphrodisiac for me?
Ahhh. Sayed.
Casey, you are funny.
Great post. I am a big lost fan, and I appreciated the religious connections. I thought it was a great season finale! Definitely some wicked mind games. Haven’t quite figured out where they are going, so it has accomplished it’s goal. That is -keeping me tuned in when the next season starts. I liked the end. I have been reading that the castaways are in some kind of weird time loop maybe. Because remember when Charlie heard that the computer was programmed by a musician? Like some kind of weird Deja Vu? Oh well, I have a little less than a year to wait.
My money’s on it being Desmond in the casket. I have my reasons – being able to say “I told you so” when I’m proven right being the foremost.
Here’s a question I had. Who’s typing on the keyboard to prevent another electromagnetic disaster during all this time? Or did I miss something? Sometimes I miss an episode.
By the way, I had a theory that Desmond is some Christ-like figure. I saw him actually playing Jesus on the religious channel.